In many cases area objects that require land, for instance island in the sea, lake or river, have an additional tag place=island/islet, like here https://osm.org/go/YnCwtMF--?layers=D&way=12379111 . However, as in the link, we cannot find any islands in the sea. Is this editing practice acceptable?

In many cases area objects that require land, for instance island in the sea, lake or river, have an additional tag place=island/islet, like here https://osm.org/go/YnCwtMF--?layers=D&way=12379111. https://osm.org/go/YnCwtMF--?layers=D&way=12379111 . However, as in the link, we cannot find any islands in the sea. Is this editing practice acceptable?

In many cases area objects that require land, for instance island in the sea, lake or river, have an additional tag place=island/islet, like here https://osm.org/go/YnCwtMF--?layers=D&way=12379111. However, as in the link, we cannot find any islands in the sea. Is this editing practice acceptable?