I am interested to use OS OpenData products as references and to upload local civil parish boundaries in my area of South Oxfordshire, perhaps. My preferred online editor is JOSM. My guess is that there are numerous means of converting the OpenData ESRI Shapefiles into .gpx or .osm file formats to open in JOSM. As I understand it, online .shp files can be viewed in Potlatch, also. I use MapInfo for processing where I can because I have amassed so much reference material with it and I am able to make small extractions of OpenData very easily by this means. I have made six .gpx files:
I opened every reprojected file in MapInfo, made my extractions and used its Universal Translator tool to make new .shp files. I used MN DNR-Garmin to create .gpx files.
I have contacted the creator of the woodland area in question but have received no reply, so I cannot yet know what method he employed. I have yet to try other methods such as ogr2osm. As I have commented previously, I am pretty hopeless with DOS and command lines. I am grateful to Chris Hill and Ed Loach, though, for pointing me in the right direction and I have downloaded Python. It remains to be seen whether I can create a .osm file for further comparison without assistance. The reason I submit this post is to determine what other contributors to OSM think about minor differences in data positions, bearing in mind our GPSr devices are only accurate to + or - three metres, say. On the other hand, should not third-party data occupy one single position, and what is the preferred method to achieve this? I should feel happier, armed with this knowledge, to upload some OpenData. I apologise, in advance, for the long-winded nature of my post! Bob Hawkins asked 08 Nov '11, 11:44 silver mapper |