Hello,

I found recently that I cannot access the upper levels of OSM using Locus for browsing the maps. I am aware that no downloading of these levels is allowed and Locus AFAIK would not allow it in the current version; but why OSM server bans usual normal browsing with Locus, showing "app is blocked" tiles instead of normal tiles? The app is actually nice browser which caches everything once seen, and I use this feature a lot, without any need for preemptive mass-downloading.

asked 30 Oct '11, 21:32

Denmes's gravatar image

Denmes
16112
accept rate: 0%

1

How would you suggest that OSM finds out if you are just viewing the tiles or downloading them?

(30 Oct '11, 21:37) Frederik Ramm ♦
1

Probably, it would be right when server would just reasonably limit the downloading rate or the number of high-resolution tiles downloaded from certain IP address in any given hour (or minute, or day, or whatever). It isn't fair to plainly ban Locus as browser because some dumbheads overload servers abusing the download feature of the generally very useful app.

(30 Oct '11, 21:52) Denmes

There is nothing the openstreetmap administrators should do about this. There is no way to detect if a user uses Locus for mass download or browsing. A filter on IP have been tryed and it gives many false positives or fails to stop abusers. It is realy hard for a computer to see the difference betwean valid users with NAT and abusers.

As far as I see Locus does most things right like limiting download rate and providing a vector map. However it seems that it is possible to download tiles for offline use (if this is not correct ask the developers to contact OSM).

If the creators of Locus would add a speccial User-Agent when the user browses the map, or disallowes download from tile.openstreetmap.org Locus will be allowed to browse all zoom levels. There are many other maps based on OSM out there and it is easy to set up your own tile server.

It is nice to see that the two most used OSM applications have moved to vector maps. Offline maps is a good selling point that others can't provide.

permanent link

answered 31 Oct '11, 00:24

Gnonthgol's gravatar image

Gnonthgol ♦
13.6k15101198
accept rate: 16%

Is it entirely forbidden to download tiles preemptively? Locus currently allows to load up to 10000 tiles per day (sized from 25 000 in previous version).

By the way, I have tried vector maps with Locus and they are quite ok, but they are lacking building numbers and other descriptions in contrast to the maps from OSM servers. Are vector maps distributed this way or the problem is caused by Locus?

And a question out of curiosity. Did administration of OSM ever think to distribute map data (tiles) by torrent? This would allow people to download what they want without overloading tile servers.

(31 Oct '11, 18:37) Denmes
3

The Tile Usage Policy says that all "bulk downloading is strongly discouraged" and that permission must be obtained in advance by the app author.

The vector data distributed by OSM contains everything we have. If Locus choose not to render all of it that's their choice.

(31 Oct '11, 21:55) Richard ♦
4

Have you worked out the implications of what you are asking? There are thousands of Locus users, if they each downloaded 10,000 tiles that is tens of millions of tiles, each day!

The answer lies in the hands of the authors of Locus. If they set up a tile server for their product then they could scale their tile server to support their customers. They would impose no load on OSM tile servers and they could provide different styles for different customers and even charge money for that. Instead they choose to free-load from the OSM tile servers and their customers are now being penalised.

(01 Nov '11, 12:05) ChrisH

There is a new blog post from the OpenStreetMap Foundation describing the challenges of serving tiles to popular applications. http://blog.osmfoundation.org/2011/11/01/tile-usage-policy/

permanent link

answered 01 Nov '11, 14:44

Richard%20Weait's gravatar image

Richard Weait
3.0k133252
accept rate: 17%

I understand the point of OSM admins pretty well, but the idea of the blocking is generally wrong, even if there's no other way for now. There should be some reasonable way to let end user download what he wants. The downloading is also a kind of use. Map caching and preemtive downloads are extremely useful when cellular internet isn't available while travelling, and even when it is - map download on-the-go may be slow and always very energy-consuming.

(01 Nov '11, 15:05) Denmes
3

Look, the situation is quite simple. OSMf does not have the recorces to allow every request to go thrugh. They are prioritizing requests from users causualy browsing the map. The alternative is to shut down the server.

If Locus wants their paying customers to mass download free maps OSMf is not the right place. They should take some of the income they make from the service and set up their own tile server. This can be done within the hour.

If OSMf had have more recorces they could accept more requests. However it is not the job of OSMf to run tile generators for software companies.

(01 Nov '11, 15:39) Gnonthgol ♦
2

"There should be some reasonable way to let end user download what he wants."

I would like some free beer every day. There should be some reasonable way to let me have what I want.

Come on!

(01 Nov '11, 18:14) Richard ♦

However it is not the job of OSMf to run tile generators for software companies.

No, there is something wrong with the logic. The access should be then also blocked for any user running Windows/MacOS, because they use paid software to access OSM and download tiles.

(01 Nov '11, 20:20) Denmes
1

"I would like some free beer every day."

No, I didn't mean it this way. The OSM foundation is giving away its stuff for free, it just don't have enough resources to service all requests. And its going to be worse in the future. At certain point the foundation may not be able to service even browsing-only users when they are numerous enough. Unfortunately, I am not educated enough in all the technical stuff to say or to do the right thing, so I'm just speculating/discussing. I am very grateful to all people who created and maintain the amazing OSM service. I just wish it to be even better.

(01 Nov '11, 20:35) Denmes

Hi guys, tile server is in preparation now. Did you read this post? http://www.openstreetmap.org/user/!i!/diary/15190. There is nice graph that show current stat. I completely! disable downloading of tiles from your server during October. So since version 1.14.0 and up, Locus is not allowed to directly download map tiles from your server, so it works only as a viewer. Is there now any chance to unblock access to tiles level 17 and higher for app with user agent Locus/1.14.0 and higher?

I hope that server will be ready till end of November so then I hope that most of current users will use this server that will serve only for Locus.

Just one think (to comment previous posts), access to maps is exactly same for Free and Pro version of app. So I don't want money from users for maps! Pro version is payed for extra functionality that offer, not for maps! And also, Free version is fully functional, not just some time limited demo, so I'm really trying to offer people fully working app and if they want some extra ...

permanent link

answered 03 Nov '11, 14:53

menion's gravatar image

menion
88114
accept rate: 0%

edited 04 Nov '11, 05:53

Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Question tags:

×6

question asked: 30 Oct '11, 21:32

question was seen: 6,058 times

last updated: 04 Nov '11, 05:53

powered by OSQA