I'd like to add a node (city centre) as a relation (admin_centre) to an administrative boundary, with JOSM, but how? This question was previously asked (and answered) here, but that only answered the part for the online website editor. asked 14 Sep '21, 22:33 Seb |
One Answer:
This should be relatively straightforward in JOSM:
More information on the relation editor can be found in the online help. There is also a completely different workflow using the Relation Toolbox Plugin if you have that installed. answered 15 Sep '21, 01:55 InsertUser |
Excellent extensive explanation, thank you!
On my system the "Edit Relation" window of JOSM opens and replaces the content of the main window, so I had to use a workaround. I had to select both the boundary and the admin_centre and then open the edit relation mode. Then I can add 'all' relations (no possibility of selecting just one), then JOSM gives a circular dependency warning and skips adding the boundary (which is great), and then it adds the admin_centre and then I can give it the proper role. If you have a way to get JOSM running as you describe, I'm interested (since it sounds more useful).
I don't think I did anything to get JOSM to do this in multiple windows. I think you may be experiencing a bug.
The only workaround I can suggest is to use the Relation Toolbox plugin which only occupies a single pane on the same side menu as the tags. The steps are broadly similar, but once a relation is selected you add the new element with the plus button in the pane and select the role from a dropdown menu.
Thanks, got it :)