Hi everyone! There is a bridge in Parnu, which is close 7pm-5am Aug 16-30 due to construction works. What's the common way of mapping this kind of information? Is there something like "conditional construction"? So far, I understand that the construction tag restricts access by default. How it would work if we add conditional access and construction tags in parallel. How OSRM routing will treat it? asked 18 Aug '21, 09:45  Bolt001 |
One Answer:
answered 19 Aug '21, 00:27  Kovoschiz edited 19 Aug '21, 00:36 |
So, basically there's no way to map such restrictions? there's another case as well, where the crossing is restricted only for cars until 31.10.2021 6pm-6am: https://www.tsk-praha.cz/wps/portal/root/o-spolecnosti/mapa-staveb?poi=606454ffd8d9a78a0e9cee3d.
It is possible to map such cases with conditional restrictions. The point is that we do not want to map such short term restrictions which lie within regular update circles of data consumers like routing apps.
@Bolt001
1. It's not "no way" to OSM. The cause is applications using OSM data usually don't update their data very frequently (even if they are not reviewed and directly used), so better keep these limited-time changes separate to avoid unintended problems. You would want to ask for the software you are using to support
temporary:*=.2. This one you can add
motor_vehicle:conditional=no @ (18:00-06:00), but you must remember to change it back. (Which is another factor not favoring maintenance of shorter period data)3. Although https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Conditional_restrictions#Use_with_keys has a
motor_vehicle:conditional=no @ (2018 May 22-2018 Oct 7)example, this is argued against in https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Proposed_features/temporary_(conditional)#Why_not_:conditional? .Thank you a lot: @TZorn and @Kovoschiz