This is a static archive of our old OpenStreetMap Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.osm.org.

How should I tag a village entrance as shown in the photo?

1

How do I tag this object which serves as the entrance of a village? I'm considering city gate or height restrictor, but none seems a good fit.

the object to be tagged

asked 24 Mar '21, 09:17

miklcct's gravatar image

miklcct
71337
accept rate: 0%

1

What is the purpose of the arch? Just information? Does it imply any legal restrictions (e.g. speed limit hereafter)?

(24 Mar '21, 09:30) TZorn

These may be worth a dedicated tag: see also this question for one in Milwaukee.

(27 Mar '21, 14:47) InsertUser

@TZorn They are more decorative and cultural (including traditions and fung shui), than informational. No legal status (not necessarily the legal indiginous village boundary either in most cases).

(28 Mar '21, 09:43) Kovoschiz
1

hi. we're talking about something related, in the new community site: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/how-to-tag-an-arch-symbolising-entry-to-area/2273/

(30 Aug '22, 20:02) mariotomo

2 Answers:

0

I think this might be considered an elaborate form of traffic_sign=city_limit and or man_made=gantry.

There is also a set of tags for welcome signs tourism=information with information=board and board_type=welcome_sign.

Tagging the clear height beneath it may also be useful for some routers.

A combination of some or all of these on a node on the road may adequately capture the meaning, but an additional short description may not be a bad idea.

answered 27 Mar '21, 15:07

InsertUser's gravatar image

InsertUser
11.0k1369185
accept rate: 19%

"Welcome signs" are usually different from these. They are symbolic marks of a rural settlement area (a few are village clusters) front, not a =city_limit legally and functionally here. As linked by you, similar ones can be for facilities, and also housing estates.

(28 Mar '21, 09:51) Kovoschiz

0

@miklcct The term "gateway" has popped up in some previous discussion. tourism=gateway is one suggestion. These are easier ones, not being a pai fong or pai lau.

answered 28 Mar '21, 09:38

Kovoschiz's gravatar image

Kovoschiz
2.4k31147
accept rate: 16%

edited 28 Mar '21, 09:39

Source code available on GitHub .