This is a static archive of our old OpenStreetMap Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.osm.org.

Should the outline of a building relation solely follow the footprint of the building, or include overhangs?

1

A Burger King building in my area has a couple of overhangs above the drive-through. I've tagged these parts building:part=roof, and the main building building:part=retail. These are included as 'part' members of the building relation.

I am unsure of how to map the 'outline' member of this relation. Should it overlap all of these building parts, or should it only overlap the building's building:part=retail (the footprint)?

asked 03 May '20, 01:42

Zismac's gravatar image

Zismac
136111117
accept rate: 0%


2 Answers:

4

In general the convention in OSM is to map the bird's-eye view & not the footprint of the building. Most building will be mapped from aerial or satellite imagery so accurate mapping of footprints requires additional on-the-ground inspection. Mapping the building as visible from above generally ensures buildings are mapped consistently.

Note that this is different from the typical approach of national topographic maps.

answered 03 May '20, 10:46

SK53's gravatar image

SK53 ♦
28.1k48268433
accept rate: 22%

1

Simple 3D Buildings, which is the tagging standard that the building:part=* key originates in, states that the building outline should overlap all the parts. That includes parts above the ground.

answered 03 May '20, 11:42

Tordanik's gravatar image

Tordanik
12.0k15106147
accept rate: 35%

Source code available on GitHub .