This is a static archive of our old OSM Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.openstreetmap.org.

Relation for a long highway

1

Hi there . Does it make sense to create a relation for specified long highway that has different segments with different attributes but belongs to a known highway?

This question is marked "community wiki".

asked 22 Mar '19, 16:31

Mehrandhn's gravatar image

Mehrandhn
11113
accept rate: 0%


2 Answers:

3

One place where it definitely makes sense is where is in countries where routes can overlap - where the same piece of road can belong to different routes. The USA is one such place - you get route signage such as this.

In other places it doesn't really make sense - in the UK for example a road will have only one UK road number.

answered 23 Mar '19, 11:04

SomeoneElse's gravatar image

SomeoneElse ♦
36.9k71370866
accept rate: 16%

18 hours without an answer and then two within 10 minutes. We should start a bus company.

(23 Mar '19, 11:16) InsertUser

1

While it might make sense, it isn't really done.

Route relations are sometimes added for numbered highways/routes that have different streetnames along their length. There are some relation types to group objects relating to a street together either for addressing or generally, but they still seem to be comparatively rare.

answered 23 Mar '19, 10:55

InsertUser's gravatar image

InsertUser
11.0k1369185
accept rate: 19%

IMHO the complication this adds and the risk of a local mapper accidentally making sweeping changes outside of their 'download window' will probably continue to outweigh the benefits of consolidating some of the tags into a higher level object (see also: the death of segments).

(23 Mar '19, 11:14) InsertUser