|
I try to create a route thru Matyholweni Gate "https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/-33.68052/25.79878" with "https://openrouteservice.org/directions?n1=-33.976855&n2=25.611663&n3=15&a=-33.982335,25.612864,-33.68047,25.798967&b=0&c=0&k1=en-US&k2=km" but the route does not go thru the gate. If I look at the gate object it is of type barrier:gate with access:yes What prevents me from routing thru the gate? Thanks, Thomas |
|
If I look at https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2124837867 (the gate where routing stops) it doesn't have any access tags so I'm not sure why you believe it is tagged "access=yes" I would suspect that routing will work once correct access tags are applied. Hi all, Thanks for your help. SimonPoole is right, there was no Access tag, my fault. I set the connection as adviced by zorglubu. I took this working gate as an example https://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=graphhopper_car&route=-33.56912%2C25.81125%3B-33.56833%2C25.81216#map=19/-33.56878/25.81170 I added Access:private and motorcar:yes to the gate: https://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/node/2124837867/ I added access:yes to the tertiary Highway: https://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/way/4281040 Still no success with GraphHopper car routing: https://www.openstreetmap.org/directions?engine=graphhopper_car&route=-33.68071%2C25.79759%3B-33.68040%2C25.79915 Any more ideas? Thanks, Thomas
(11 Oct '17, 09:05)
thgx
1
It might take some time (days or weeks) for a router to start using your changes to OSM - you'll need to be patient.
(11 Oct '17, 09:19)
SomeoneElse ♦
1
The
(11 Oct '17, 10:05)
scai ♦
|
|
Have a look at the barrier=gate to the East of your lift_gate. It clearly says access=private. Your software obviously will not route through there, eventhough it has the motorcar=yes tag which does not make sense. OSM wiki defines access=private as "Only with permission of the owner on an individual basis". ownership should be permissive for private toll roads. I added acces=private (see my "answer" below). Now I changed it to access=yes, still no success
(11 Oct '17, 09:15)
thgx
2
Routing engines take a while to update (usually between a day and a month), so don't expect the change to take effect immediately.
(11 Oct '17, 09:58)
Richard ♦
|
|
Looking at the routing engines on osm.org, most seem just fine with that gate. Only graphhopper's car routing struggles. Whether routing should stop at a gate on a tertiary road with no explicit access tags is a moot point - I'd suggest that it shouldn't, though whoever implements a router can do so if they wish. |
|
Hello Thomas, Zoom-in quite a lot, and move your gate exactly on the boundary. The colour of this boundary will change, indicating that it's sticking. Release the mouse bouton. Check by moving again the gate and CTRL-Z. |
There are actually two barriers. https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2124837867 and https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2124837858
As an aside to this particular question - it's not a good idea to "tag for the router". It might be perfectly valid for a router not to route past a particular sort of barrier - or a conscious decision by whoever designed the router.
This doesn't sound like the problem here of course - from what you're saying the gate will always be raised to let cars through but lowered to stop elephants.