Hi, do any of you have or know where I could get maps including war cemeteries / memorials. I saw there was a WWI memorials project but don't know how to contact them. If not is anyone interested in working with me. I am new so would need help and guidance but am eager to learn. Thanks

asked 14 Jun '11, 11:41

Gopsall's gravatar image

Gopsall
16112
accept rate: 0%

edited 14 Jun '11, 11:42


OSM has a limited amount of information about war memorials and cemeteries.

We do not have a specific map showing them, although using JXAPI it should be possible to extract them all: I imagine there are still only several hundred. If you want to make a custom map, Maperitive is probably the easiest route. Memorials of all kinds will be shown at high zoom levels on the main map (although they may be suppressed when there is a lot of detail).

At my suggestion we had a Project of the Week in 2010 to coincide with Armistice Day which is a day on which people killed in wars and conflicts are remembered in several countries. Most people interested in this topic will add new memorials as they come across them. See these blog posts from people who did a bit of surveying at the time: Open Maps, Tlatet and Weait.

There are a number of ways in which we could increase the amount of data we have: primarily by enabling OSM to use other sources in various ways: either by being allowed to derive from their work (e.g. a geolocated photograph) or by importing their data. If you are interested in adding to the information we have on War Memorials there is a lot that can be done by building relationships and contacts with these other groups. I imagine many would be interested if they got useful map resources in return.

I am aware of a number of other groups collating information on war memorials in the UK, but many have restrictions as to how their data can be used and these usually mean the data is not compatible with the licenses used by OpenStreetMap. For instance there is a very large body of geolocated photographs associated with memorials to the Royal Air Force.

Alternatively these sources of information could be used as the basis for surveying memorials explicitly for OSM. Again, a British example, but the Commonwealth War Graves Commission have a large amount of information which if released under a suitable license, could be used for locating and mapping war cemeteries (particularly as these will now be visible with Bing Imagery, which was not available last year.

These notes have a British bias, but the same principle applies in other countries: I'm just not familiar with the various official or charitable bodies which look after war graves and cemeteries. The Stolpersteine project is another example of something of a similar nature: but carried out much more systematically.

permanent link

answered 14 Jun '11, 15:36

SK53's gravatar image

SK53 ♦
19.5k40206311
accept rate: 20%

http://www.flickr.com/photos/sk53_osm/5833673984 for an example of Maperitive output showing memorials explicitly tagged as war memorials. Many war memorials will not have this tag. The companion image shows all memorial nodes (these may include things like Blue Plaques, memorials to literary figures etc): http://www.flickr.com/photos/sk53_osm/5833118405.

(14 Jun '11, 20:02) SK53 ♦

By the way, as of now December 2012, Richard Weait's blog website - at http://weait.com - seems to be no longer active...

PS A presentation from him about OSM : http://fr.slideshare.net/rweait/ and a video with him : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tWCGkAZtnME

(30 Nov '12, 11:32) Pascal Boule...

The WW1 memorial project in the UK is the UK Inventory of War Memorials. Their data licence is not compatible with OSM and they do not seem keen to cooperate with OSM, in spite of initial interest.

There is nothing to stop OSM mapping memorials separately from UKIWM, indeed if we do a good job it may encourage more cooperation. I have surveyed some of the memorials listed in their database and their records are badly out-of-data. Many of their records are taken from press cuttings printed during or just after the 1914-19 war, and the actual memorial has long ago disappeared. Their project is about updating their records rather than mapping them. The grid references they use are 6-figure OS references (poor resolution by OSM standards) and these are low quality too. I have volunteered to improve the data, but it is a huge task, especially because the data and photographs supplied to do the job is very poor quality. The project is crying out to be crowd-sourced. My enthusiasm has faded by the boring way the data has to be processed.

permanent link

answered 14 Jun '11, 21:30

ChrisH's gravatar image

ChrisH
4.1k124262
accept rate: 15%

edited 14 Jun '11, 21:42

Hi Chris, when you say that their data licence is not compatible, but say that you have volunteered to improve the data, how would one go about doing that?

For example, can we add their ref number to OSM? If I went out to Newsells, for example, to survey it, what data do we collect and in what format; and how are they interested in our updates?

http://www.ukniwm.org.uk/server/show/conMemorial.48141

You're right about it being cried out to be crowd-sourced though - I've no real interest in going out and about 'bagging' war memorials, though quite happy to log data in my local villages...C.

(16 Jun '11, 21:32) c2r

I asked if they would release any of their data for use in OSM. They said no. That's what I meant by not compatible. Volunteering involved checking what they have already in their database by comparing it with supplied images.

Adding their memorial ID might be useful, but I would not use it without their permission.

I have checked that some of our local memorials are correctly positioned and tagged in OSM, I believe we could use the data in their data base to try to locate a real memorial on the ground and then use that survey to update OSM.

(16 Jun '11, 22:41) ChrisH

Thanks, that makes sense... I think at the moment then it is their loss if they're not interested in open data, so I'll not worry about their memorial ID (o;

(16 Jun '11, 23:10) c2r

big cemeteries will show on satellite images which you could map ..If you type war memorial into the search box of map page it will list some that are mapped and there location

permanent link

answered 14 Jun '11, 15:26

andy%20mackey's gravatar image

andy mackey
10.7k69116243
accept rate: 4%

edited 14 Jun '11, 21:56

and I've added two local memorials,a lot of villages have them I'm sure emailing village sites would yield more

(14 Jun '11, 22:01) andy mackey
Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Question tags:

×2
×1

question asked: 14 Jun '11, 11:41

question was seen: 2,493 times

last updated: 30 Nov '12, 11:32

powered by OSQA