|
Hello, There is a discussion going on on this changeset. Basically, this is a mini_roundabout but there are elevated physical features on the ground already in the database, from a high accuracy source:
So the question is how to settle the case, as the roads could be drawn going straight to the only node at the center of the mini-roundabout, thus crossing the traffic_calming features (which are also used by pedestrians when crossing). The wiki discussion page mentions area=yes, but it seems not widespread, as well as having a circular way closed as a mini_roundabout. In case you want, here is a good aerial photography: |
|
mini roundabouts in the legal and OSM sense don't really exist in Switzerland, what does exist are traffic calming features that look like mini roundabouts. As always in OSM more detail is quite permissible and given what I've already said I can't see a reason to replace the existing detail with a simplified and potentially wrong modelling. Notes:
What you say is tricky, because it presents all the features of a mini_roundabout: drivers have to behave as in a roundabout, but it can be crossed: trucks and buses can drive on it easily. Also, it as the signs designating a roundabout. No need for Mapillary data, I just went there to take pictures.
(30 May '17, 13:33)
Xinfe
3
The circle line around the middle is a full line and you are not allowed to cross it with a vehicle see SR 741.21 (SSV) Art. 73
(30 May '17, 14:16)
SimonPoole ♦
Fantastic detailed answer, thanks! :) (It can be read as ironic, but I really mean it) The case is settled, then!
(30 May '17, 14:21)
Xinfe
|
