This is a static archive of our old OpenStreetMap Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.osm.org.

US Forest Service roads with multiple names

0

Major Forest Service roads around here generally have two names: a number, and a textual name. For example, one road is interchangeably referred to as "Lightning Creek Road" and "Road 419", including on signs (signs might have one name, the other, or both). How should I handle this?

asked 27 Jan '16, 06:55

Carnildo's gravatar image

Carnildo
831212543
accept rate: 40%

edited 27 Jan '16, 06:56


One Answer:

4

How about name=Lightning Creek Road and ref=419?

answered 27 Jan '16, 06:59

Lightsider's gravatar image

Lightsider
1.5k52129
accept rate: 42%

Would this make both names show up on the map?

(27 Jan '16, 14:54) ChrisMendez
2

Or maybe ref=FS 419.

(It's not really clear to me what the prefix should be for US Forest Service road refs, but I think they should have some prefix to help finding them)

(27 Jan '16, 14:55) maxerickson
1

ref=FS xxx is indeed fairly commonly used in my experience.

(27 Jan '16, 14:58) Richard ♦

1 and 2 digit routes should be FS as they're part of the National Forest Service highway system. 3 and 4 digit routes are almost always NFD as part of the National Forest Development trail system. This isn't always hard and firm in terms of the number of digits, but in general if it's a trapezoid brown sign, it's FS, if it's a rectangular horizontal brown sign or vertical brown sign, it's NFD.

(27 Jan '16, 18:57) Baloo Uriza

Source code available on GitHub .