4
1

Hello, there.

My question is simple, but I can't find a simple answer: when mapping POI such as shops on a zone where street numbers already exist, should I map the POI on the street number node or map the POI on a separate node at the same location? My question seems rather trivial, but, strangely, I couldn't find any similar questions, so, if I missed them, please don't hit too hard.

Awaiting your answers,

Regards.

asked 15 Dec '15, 14:14

Penegal's gravatar image

Penegal
631293345
accept rate: 0%


Your question is not trivial :) As far as I know there is no one definitive answer, but my take would be:

  • If a POI is the only "object of note" at a given address (i.e. if given POI is only thing worth tagging at that address), then tag the address node with the POI tags. This is essentially the one object, one element guideline, and helps to clearly associate a POI with that street address.
  • If there could be several POIs associated with a particular address (e.g. a building with several shops in it), then tag the POI as a separate node.
permanent link

answered 15 Dec '15, 15:38

Lightsider's gravatar image

Lightsider
1.5k52129
accept rate: 42%

1

Does the second possibility include shared buildings? I mean, at least here in France, downtown buildings often have a shop at the ground floor and apartments above, but, then, shop and apartments share the same address; should I anyway map the POI on a different node?

(15 Dec '15, 16:15) Penegal

Besides, if the POI is on a different node, how do I map its address? Wouldn't it create a duplicate content?

(15 Dec '15, 19:41) Penegal

I would suppose these have different subaddresses then, but the wiki pages say nothing about mapping subaddresses. If there really is only one adress for the building, with several POIs inside, wouldn't it be an option to tag the address to just the building?

(16 Dec '15, 07:30) joost schouppe

If the addr:housenumber is a separate node I do not need to add address tags on the shop/amenity, this is usually the case when the building and the shop has different entrances. So if the only entrance to the building is through the shop I map the address tag on the shop.

(16 Dec '15, 13:24) emj

But, by not tagging the shop on the same node that its address, the link between the address and the shop would not be established, and that's whats bothers me; OSM allows one to add shops addresses, phone numbers and websites, but the postal address cannot be added if the building is shared? Sounds strange to me.

(16 Dec '15, 14:05) Penegal
2

Some software (e.g. Nominatim) can extract the address from the building (area) and assign it to the POIs inside. Other software does not do this. You can always duplicate the address information on the node of the POI. I wouldn't tag the address info on a node when it applies to the whole building, but in some countries you are not supposed to do this (e.g. Denmark)

You could of course have an address node and a separate POI node with the same address in 1 building, if needed.

(17 Dec '15, 08:23) escada

Then I'll map the POI address in its node in addition of the address node, but I'll only put the address node in the street relation, not the POI node. Thanks for your help.

(17 Dec '15, 09:42) Penegal
showing 5 of 7 show 2 more comments
Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Question tags:

×154
×154
×144
×108
×54

question asked: 15 Dec '15, 14:14

question was seen: 2,752 times

last updated: 17 Dec '15, 09:42

powered by OSQA