Is there a way of finding waterways which have been deleted during the redaction process? (usually waterway=stream) I have been checking waterways using OSMi, and have found a lot of them deleted by the redaction bot during the license change in 2012. Now, this means that the water network is disjointed in the map; unlike highways, this has gone unnoticed for so long that I can't find any post-redaction QA tools. An example to clarify:
asked 25 Oct '14, 21:41 Piskvor |
As far as I know we had post-redaction tools which showed where the bot was active, but I currently do not remember them, and I guess they may be shut down already (redaction is quite some time ago). These general QA tools may help: (the one which you already used …) OSMI for waterways (makes it much easier to see and follow the waterways) and (for central/eastern Europe around Germany) Martin Kompf's rivermap (disjoint rivers are grey) may help. answered 25 Oct '14, 23:21 aseerel4c26 ♦ 2
I have initially discovered the issue while using OSMi; the rivermap seems to be the tool I'm looking for. Thank you!
(27 Oct '14, 10:22)
Piskvor
|
A new set of inspections is now available in the OSMi Water layer, which also addresses this type of error: http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=water ( See also the blog post: http://blog.geofabrik.de/en/?p=323 ) answered 07 Dec '15, 11:51 Piskvor |
Hi Piskvor, if the rivers or streams are removed by the BOT it has to be. The mappers who made them in OSM failed to subscribe to the new rules so the DATA could not be continued. I dont expect them to get a restoration. It would create the unlicensed import of DATA. Could you still provide a link to the region ? answered 25 Oct '14, 23:01 Hendrikklaas 4
as I understand it, the question is not about the undeletion/reverting of the bot but to just know where approximately the bot edited waterways and to re-map the waterways then from scratch (with own survey or bing). This may be okay, even without a agreement of the original mappers.
(25 Oct '14, 23:11)
aseerel4c26 ♦
Thank you, I may have been unclear: I'm not trying to restore the deleted data; I'm quite aware they were deleted for a reason. I'm trying to find what really existing features were deleted, so I can resurvey them.
(27 Oct '14, 10:21)
Piskvor
|