1
1

While mapping, I've recently come across roads that are very likely not to exist, at least when comparing their course to Bing (and other) satellite imagery.

For example, I saw a road that, according to Bing, ended at a specific point. However, in OSM it was mapped as continuing after that point and it was even shown as being connected to another road. According to Bing and other satellite layers, it looked like there could not even be a path where this road was mapped.

So, is it suitable to remove the road where it probably doesn't exist, even though I'm not a local mapper and cannot verify this 100%?

asked 03 Oct '14, 09:04

Maturi0n's gravatar image

Maturi0n
446610
accept rate: 0%

1

You could add the osm url of the road to you query and someone local may recognise the area and may be able to verify. It could have been recently constructed though it seems as though you are viewing quite recent imagery to be so confident.

(03 Oct '14, 09:19) nevw
1

Please do add a OSM URL to one of the places in question. If it is the United States, especially if it is in the rural western United States, it may be one of the old Tiger data imports which are notoriously inaccurate and definitely need to be cleaned up. If you are using JOSM there is a Tiger 2013 overlay which is generally better and can assist in cleaning up. But even that is far from perfect. It could be that ID and/or Potlatch have that image overlay too but I don't use them so I can't say.

(03 Oct '14, 17:21) stf

(re the "where in the world is this question about") I'd assumed from this previous question that it's actually Ukraine and/or Moldova.

(03 Oct '14, 18:55) SomeoneElse ♦
2

As I am relatively new to OSM, I sadly don't know how to get a link to those roads. The concerned objects where "Krasnyj per." (Красный пер.) and a nameless road next to it, in the village of Parkany (Парканы) in Transnistria/Moldova. Sadly I don't know any local mappers, I know a person that lives there and that confirmed to me that both roads were mapped incorrectly. I have corrected this since then.

Whenever I stumble across such problems again, I will just leave a note, except for the rare cases where I have a local source. Thanks for the tips.

(03 Oct '14, 21:33) Maturi0n

to post a map link just zoom into the place in question then cut and paste this bit above the map, it this it? http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/83039146#map=16/46.8232/29.5197

(03 Oct '14, 22:52) andy mackey

The only way to be really sure is to go and have a look, so personally I'd add a note suggesting that there might be a problem so that a local mapper can investigate. It's fairly easy to get OSM notes local to an area (so easy that even I wrote something to do that), and local mappers can see and act on them.

As an alternative, perhaps find the main communications mechanisms that the local community uses (which might be mailing lists, forum, IRC or something else) and ask there? Someone may be able to give you an answer straight away.

permanent link

answered 03 Oct '14, 09:35

SomeoneElse's gravatar image

SomeoneElse ♦
33.0k65343778
accept rate: 16%

2

You could also mail the mapper that added it, remember that bing imagery can be several years out of date and a new road could have been constructed.

(03 Oct '14, 16:03) trig222
2

Further note: the original question didn't indicate -where- he was editing. While the answers in general are correct, in the USA uncorrected TIGER data can be multiple kilometers off in some areas and can seem to be completly unrelated to aerial imagery.

(03 Oct '14, 18:51) SimonPoole ♦
Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Question tags:

×7
×5

question asked: 03 Oct '14, 09:04

question was seen: 2,374 times

last updated: 03 Oct '14, 22:59

powered by OSQA