This is a static archive of our old OpenStreetMap Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.osm.org.

Why is there no live editing in Potlatch 2 and iD?

1
1

Why is there no live editing in Potlatch Two and iD?

asked 23 Apr '13, 17:36

erkinalp's gravatar image

erkinalp
403412
accept rate: 0%

edited 28 May '13, 13:58


One Answer:

7

Because to implement it would be insanely complex, especially with a full-featured undo system. The tiny number of people who find it important don't merit the resources required.

answered 23 Apr '13, 17:41

Richard's gravatar image

Richard ♦
30.9k44279412
accept rate: 18%

7

Or to give another perspective: live editing is scarily dangerous, and I am glad it's (almost) gone.

(23 Apr '13, 18:40) Vincent de P... ♦

I realized the danger but I am a responsible man, and experienced enough for live editing. My choice is always live editing in Potlatch One. And I am ready for live editing without undo support.

(28 Apr '13, 17:29) erkinalp
2

Sorry - there simply aren't enough people like you to make it worthwhile coding the feature. You could of course code it yourself, but I doubt it'd be deployed on osm.org.

(28 Apr '13, 18:16) Richard ♦

Source code available on GitHub .