4
1

I know that Points Of Interest are in the database. Is it possible to see them in a browser? For example, I can search for "campground" in google maps and it will show them as little red dots.

If this isn't implemented, I would like to know is anyone working on this and what is the way this is planned to be implemented?

I know there is some derivation of openstreetmap at http://www.openstreetbrowser.org, but it has totally different tile rendering and many POIs don't show (like camping). Also many tiles are missing. Also I found a missing lake in California!

So any idea how to get similar functionality to openstreetmap?

asked 08 Oct '12, 23:13

zubr's gravatar image

zubr
76567
accept rate: 0%

edited 09 Oct '12, 11:56

SomeoneElse's gravatar image

SomeoneElse ♦
33.3k65347792


The main page does show some POIs including camp sites (example), but not every possible map feature as this would make the map too cluttered.

The tile rendering style of OpenStreetBrowser is just a configuration issue and many other maps also use slightly different styles for their tiles. There are also lots of other OSM based services. Some are interactive like OpenStreetBrowser allowing to select specific POIs to show, like OSM POI Viewer (standard rendering style) and FLOSM (custom rendering style). Others just have different POI rendering priorities like the Hike & Bike map where camp sites already show up at lower zoom levels.

There is also a list of current Top Ten Tasks including clickable POIs on the frontpage. This might also lead to different POI layers in the end, let's see.

permanent link

answered 09 Oct '12, 07:44

scai's gravatar image

scai ♦
32.0k20293443
accept rate: 23%

The front page of osm.org isn't supposed to be a "Google Maps replacement" - the standard map is just an example showing what you can do with the data.

There are a few other examples out there: Mapquest Open is one, and this one by Nicolas Dumoulin is another.

permanent link

answered 09 Oct '12, 12:07

SomeoneElse's gravatar image

SomeoneElse ♦
33.3k65347792
accept rate: 15%

1

Having many different sites each having various extra features implemented is horrible from the standpoint of promotion of the idea of openmaps to simple users. openstreetmap.org has nice maps but no POIs, openstretbrowser.org has one coloful map and some POIs and missing data, dimoulin63.net has yet one other rendering and 5 POI types display.

Which one should simple users (non-geeks) use that would like to use openmaps? Even for geeks, this isn't right.

(09 Oct '12, 16:58) zubr
1

I understand your frustration. I'm a centre-thinking person & this whole project is quite frustrating to define. Right or wrong, OSM promoted itself as "Wikipedia of maps" - but it's only a database of geo-objects - a subset of this appears on the main map. The data is free for others to create their own maps, but the manner in which they render it is out of OSMs control. OSM has tried to be ordinary-person friendly, but firmly remains a geeky backwater. It doesn't want to be "mainstream". This identity confuses people, and I believe causes them to lose interest. Refer to OSMF for reasons why.

(09 Oct '12, 17:49) wolftracker
2

Both these comments are well-founded, but the hard fact is that it takes people to build all this good stuff. Clickable POIs have been a high-priority item on the Top Ten Tasks for a year now, and still no-one has stepped up to build it. Saying "it isn't right" is fine, but doesn't help to get the job done; we can't just magic features out of nowhere. Perhaps you could help?

(09 Oct '12, 18:46) Richard ♦
1

@zubr: The "but which one should I use" question isn't a new one. The fundamental difference between e.g. Google Maps and OSM is that people here are volunteers. As scai says, clickable POIs on the frontpage is on a list of "top ten tasks" - it "just" needs people to volunteer to help with it.

Incidentally, to correct a couple of points about Nick Dumoulin's map that I linked to - you can select from more than just the 5 canned queries - just select the "custom request" link, and it's not "yet another rendering" - it uses Mapquest tiles by default as a background or (if you select it) OSM's "standard" map.

(09 Oct '12, 19:02) SomeoneElse ♦

Hi there! I've been experimenting a little bit with doing something like that, showing POIs on the map. I just have the problem that my laptop is a quite bit slow, and have overheating problems. But I might be able to continue my experiments on a friends computer. I guess that if it's good enough, they'll put it on the main OSM page.

permanent link

answered 09 Oct '12, 05:54

knarF's gravatar image

knarF
111
accept rate: 0%

There is a new website called MAPCAT that uses vector maps based on OSM and allows to show POI search results directly on the map in real time - just go to the website, zoom your map to your desired location and enter "restaurant" or "campsite" into search box in the top left corner of the page and the results will appear on the map immediately. Nice, isn't it?

permanent link

answered 01 Aug '17, 11:07

Kozuch's gravatar image

Kozuch
1.6k577282
accept rate: 8%

Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Question tags:

×164

question asked: 08 Oct '12, 23:13

question was seen: 8,069 times

last updated: 01 Aug '17, 11:07

powered by OSQA