This is a static archive of our old OpenStreetMap Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.osm.org.

Zählen Parkplätze von Geschäften zu normalen “Parkplätzen”?

Zählen Parkplätze von Geschäften und Supermärkten zu normalen Parkplätzen oder gehören diese in eine andere Kategorie? Danke!

English Version:

Count parking spaces of shops and supermarkets to normal parking spaces or are those in another category? Thank you!

supermarkt slot parking parkplätze lang-de

asked 19 Feb '12, 17:42

Applefreak127
101●3●3●9
accept rate: 0%

edited 13 Apr '13, 13:34

aseerel4c26 ♦
32.6k●18●248●554

One Answer:

Diese werden genauso als Parkplätze eingetragen, du solltest jedoch zusätzlich zu amenity=parking auch access=permissive setzen (es gibt auch access=customer, aber darüber ist man sich noch nicht ganz einig).

answered 19 Feb '12, 18:34

scai ♦
33.3k●21●309●459
accept rate: 23%

access=permissive ist im Allgemeinen nicht korrekt: Ein Kundenparkplatz ist normalerweise gerade nicht "open to general traffic" (wie in der Definition von permissive gefordert), sondern darf nur von Kunden genutzt werden.

Einfach amenity=parking + access=customer verwenden. Das Tag ist zwar neu, aber alle vorhandenen passen einfach nicht wirklich auf diese Situation.

(20 Feb '12, 14:24) Tordanik

Why can't you simply do a -1 to comments?

I disagree with @Tordanik and agree with the initial answer. access=permissive is exactly what everyone was told to use for a pub parking when I joined OSM in 2007. Please stop endlessly redefining tags.

(13 Apr '13, 16:07) cartinus

@cartinus: It is true there is some discussion about the access=customer tagging, but access=permissive is definitely wrong, as explained by Tordanik. The alternatives usually proposed for access=customer are access=destination or access=customers; see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/customer and its talk page.

(15 Apr '13, 22:41) sleske

Also note that access=customers (note the 's') is recommended, not access=customer. It's also used much more frequently in OSM.

(15 Apr '13, 22:49) sleske

And I reiterate: access=permissive is and has been the right way for years.

Then five people on a mailinglist or in a wiki proposal page "decide" differently. That is the best way to make tags in OSM useless. Please stop catering to such nonsense.

access=destination on a parking lot is just stupid. The parking lot is always the destination, when you park a car there, so that tag adds absolutely nothing.

(15 Apr '13, 22:52) cartinus