Zählen Parkplätze von Geschäften und Supermärkten zu normalen Parkplätzen oder gehören diese in eine andere Kategorie? Danke! English Version: Count parking spaces of shops and supermarkets to normal parking spaces or are those in another category? Thank you! asked 19 Feb '12, 17:42 Applefreak127 edited 13 Apr '13, 13:34 aseerel4c26 ♦ |
One Answer:
Diese werden genauso als Parkplätze eingetragen, du solltest jedoch zusätzlich zu amenity=parking auch access=permissive setzen (es gibt auch access=customer, aber darüber ist man sich noch nicht ganz einig). answered 19 Feb '12, 18:34 scai ♦ |
access=permissive ist im Allgemeinen nicht korrekt: Ein Kundenparkplatz ist normalerweise gerade nicht "open to general traffic" (wie in der Definition von permissive gefordert), sondern darf nur von Kunden genutzt werden.
Einfach amenity=parking + access=customer verwenden. Das Tag ist zwar neu, aber alle vorhandenen passen einfach nicht wirklich auf diese Situation.
Why can't you simply do a -1 to comments?
I disagree with @Tordanik and agree with the initial answer. access=permissive is exactly what everyone was told to use for a pub parking when I joined OSM in 2007. Please stop endlessly redefining tags.
@cartinus: It is true there is some discussion about the
access=customer
tagging, butaccess=permissive
is definitely wrong, as explained by Tordanik. The alternatives usually proposed foraccess=customer
areaccess=destination
oraccess=customers
; see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/customer and its talk page.Also note that
access=customers
(note the 's') is recommended, notaccess=customer
. It's also used much more frequently in OSM.And I reiterate: access=permissive is and has been the right way for years.
Then five people on a mailinglist or in a wiki proposal page "decide" differently. That is the best way to make tags in OSM useless. Please stop catering to such nonsense.
access=destination on a parking lot is just stupid. The parking lot is always the destination, when you park a car there, so that tag adds absolutely nothing.