This is a static archive of our old OpenStreetMap Help Site. Please post any new questions and answers at community.osm.org.

Why is state of NJ so much greener than the rest of the map

1

Is there really a need to paint every clump of trees on private property green? Shouldn't it be reserved for public parks and forest reserves only?

asked 22 Jan '12, 03:48

Alhimik's gravatar image

Alhimik
16111
accept rate: 0%


2 Answers:

2

What appears on the default Mapnik map is a compromise - it does show "every clump of trees" (or every natural=wood at any rate). The reason why NJ's so much greener than neighbouring states is that woodland data appears to have been imported for it by this account. Looking at the map N of Trenton it seems to include "land that is sometimes used for growing trees" rather than "land that has trees on it as at the time of the Bing imagery".

Other renderings are available - you may find that this one fits better with leftpondian expectations of what a map shoould look like.

answered 22 Jan '12, 13:03

SomeoneElse's gravatar image

SomeoneElse ♦
36.9k71370866
accept rate: 16%

Other renderings are available - you may find that this one fits better with leftpondian expectations of what a map shoould look like.

It seems that mapquest suffers from the same problem. There need to be some very specific rules regarding what to paint when, as this is clearly a mess.

(26 Jan '12, 01:25) Alhimik

0

The data is valid and appropriate to OSM, all the way down to individual trees on private property - if the mapper has determined that the data is correct and current.

The New Jersey land use data has been mass imported from other public data sources. It's my opinion that such a mass import does not add value to the OSM data:

  1. OSM editors such as Potlatch and JOSM do not separate the landuse data at edit time, thus massively complicating future edits.
  2. Mappers who improve or create landuse polygons stand to lose their work if newer data is imported.
  3. Public land use data would be better stored in a separate database, and combined with OSM data at render time to create colored maps - if needed by the desired render style.

answered 22 Jan '12, 13:14

Mike%20N's gravatar image

Mike N
2.9k22254
accept rate: 17%

Source code available on GitHub .